Skip navigation

Review guidelines

Four requirements, eight exclusions and four rules of conduct for businesses. They apply equally to every reviewer and every company.

Requirements

A review must be:

  • First-hand. You dealt with the company yourself, in roughly the last few years, by buying from it, hiring it, booking with it or getting a quote.
  • Specific. The useful facts are the item or the job, the quoted price against the final one, the timing, and the handling of any problem. A fact is worth more to the next customer than an adjective.
  • Fair. An account of events and of your treatment, without insults. Strong opinions are permitted.
  • Of useful length. Between 40 and 3,000 characters.

Exclusions

Excluded from publication:

  • Reviews by conflicted authors: staff of the company or of a rival, family of either, or anyone paid by either.
  • Incentivized reviews: any review given in exchange for a reward, whether a discount, gift, payment or prize-draw entry.
  • Misdirected reviews, where the subject is another company, or a manufacturer, marketplace seller or payment provider and not the business under review.
  • Duplicates: a second review by one author of one company before 30 days have passed.
  • Contact information of any kind: links, phone numbers and email addresses, as well as the full name or contact details of an employee.
  • Abusive content: threats, harassment, hate speech, sexual material, or swearing directed at a person.
  • Text copied from elsewhere, or produced with AI tools instead of describing your own experience.
  • Allegations that someone committed a crime, which belong with the police or other authorities. Describing your own experience remains allowed.

Business conduct

A business may ask every one of its customers for a review. A business may not:

  • Give anything of value for a review, positive or otherwise.
  • Invite only satisfied customers, or deter dissatisfied ones from reviewing.
  • Post reviews of its own business or of a rival, directly or through employees, family members or agencies.
  • Use pressure or threats to make a reviewer alter or take down a review.

Basis: the Federal Trade Commission’s Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465. Any review obtained in breach of these rules is removed.

Decisions and appeals

A moderator reads each review written on Mile Marker before publication. When a review is rejected, the reason is recorded. To ask for a second look, contact us with the company’s name and the email address you used. A moderator will then reconsider the decision.