1. Publication
Every review written on Mile Marker enters as pending. A moderator compares it with the review guidelines, then publishes or rejects it. A pending or rejected review does not appear on a listing and does not count toward a score.
The moderator checks four things:
- First-hand. The author was the customer: the order, booking, visit or quote happened to them, with this company.
- Content. Nothing that identifies or endangers a person stays in: no links, no phone numbers, no personal details about employees, no threats, no hate speech.
- Origin. Repeated posts by one person are flagged, as are reviews by the company’s own staff or by its competitors.
- Frequency. One review per company, per author, every 30 days.
A company may reply to any review in public. It may not edit, hide or remove a review, and no payment changes how a review is handled. Critical and favorable reviews go through the same process, on the same terms.
2. The score
Definition: the score equals the sum of the star ratings in a company’s published reviews divided by their number, shown to one decimal place. It is a plain average. Estimates, paid weighting and manual corrections play no part in it.
Below 5 published reviews the score is provisional: the number is shown in grey, because a few reviews can move it a long way. From 5 reviews on, the bar beside the score turns red and one of five bands applies.
| Band | Score | Shown as |
|---|---|---|
| Exceptional | 4.5 – 5.0 | 4.7 |
| Above standard | 4.0 – 4.4 | 4.2 |
| Meets standard | 3.0 – 3.9 | 3.4 |
| Below standard | 2.0 – 2.9 | 2.5 |
| Unacceptable | 1.0 – 1.9 | 1.6 |
Sales score and work score
Each reviewer records the type of dealing: Sale, Pre-sale, Work or Unlisted. Once enough reviewers have answered, a listing shows two further averages: a sales score, from Sale and Pre-sale reviews, and a work score, from Work reviews. A company can sell well and do the work poorly, or the reverse.
Detail ratings and price questions
Reviewers may also rate four details (Accurate information, Price transparency, Efficiency, Delivered as specified) and answer two yes-or-no questions: whether the final charge was identical to the quote, and whether any charge was added without being disclosed in advance. Each of these figures appears on a listing once 5 reviewers have answered it.
The order index
Lists sorted by rating use the order index, not the score. The order index also accounts for how many reviews a company has. A company with three five-star reviews does not sort above one with forty reviews averaging 4.8.
Each company starts with 5 assumed reviews of 3.5 stars. As its real reviews accumulate, they move the index toward its actual average:
order index = (3.5 × 5 + S) ÷ (5 + n)
S is the star ratings of all published reviews, added together. n is the number of published reviews. The order index only sorts lists and is never displayed. A listing always shows the score.
3. Sources
A line under each review states where it came from.
| Line under the review | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Source: the Mile Marker review form, completed by the customer | Written by the customer on this site. |
| Source: the company's own feedback form, completed by a customer | The company gathered it from its customers and forwarded it to us. We refuse any feedback the company picked out, altered or paid for. |
| No line | First published by the customer on another review platform, and shown here as it was published there. |
4. Listings and claims
Source of a listing: business information, collected and checked by us. It covers name, address, phone number and website. Closed companies, and listings whose details can no longer be confirmed, are taken out of view, not erased. Their reviews are kept.
Claiming is open to every company and costs nothing. It grants two things: the ability to correct the listing’s details, and the ability to reply to customers. It changes nothing in the score.
5. Reports
Each review carries a Report link. Use it when a review breaks the guidelines, concerns a different company, or appears not to be genuine. A moderator examines every report, then removes the review, keeps it, or asks the reviewer for more detail. The review stays visible while its report is examined.